The post test prob of a negative mod sgarbossa would be incredibly low and all but rule out occlusion steve smith. Validation of smith modified sgarbossa criteria published. In 1996, sgarbossa et al26 published an analysis from the gusto1 trial evaluating different ecg criteria to diagnose ami in the presence of lbbb. Conflicts of interest comprise financial interests, activities, and relationships within the past 3 years including but not limited to employment, affiliation, grants or funding, consultancies, honoraria or payment, speakers bureaus, stock ownership or options, expert testimony, royalties, donation of medical. Acute myocardial infarction ami in the presence of left bundle branch block lbbb is a diagnostic challenge for the physician. Thus, the higher sgarbossa criteria scoring in the case was the only. The left bundlebranch block puzzle in the 20 stelevation. In the text below the calculator there is more information on the original and modified criteria and on the research. Validation of smith modified sgarbossa criteria published in. The trial concluded that the three electrocardiographic criteria with independent value in the diagnosis of acute infarction were stsegment elevation of at least 1mm that was concordant with the qrs odds ratio 25. Sgarbossa e, pinski s, et al for the gusto1 investigators. Sgarbossa criteria in left bundle branch block in a. In a previous article i showed this graphic which was created using powerpoint. From falsely declaring emergency to denying reperfusion in a highrisk population.
Left bundle branch block lbbb is the consequence of anatomical or functional dysfunction in the left bundle branch, causing the impulse to be blocked. Sgarbossas is a well accepted approach at determining which lbbb are having an mi. Criteria for the diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction in the presence of left bundlebranch block were developed from two populations the study and control groups, which. Lbbb with the ekgs of an equal number of patients with stable angiographically documented cad and complete lbbb but no chest pain at the time of ekg. Sgarbossa criteria in bundle branch blocks and paced rhythm.
Dec 03, 20 ideally, diagnostic tests for lifethreatening conditions i. Here is a similar graphic i created this morning by cropping actual ecgs. Sgarbossa criteria for acute myocardial infarction ncbi. The trial concluded that the three electrocardiographic criteria with independent value in the diagnosis of acute infarction were stsegment. The most important change is the modification of the rule for excessive discordance the use of a 5 mm cutoff for excessive discordance was arbitrary and nonspecific for example, patients with lbbb and large voltages will commonly. Pendell meyers had just graduated from college when he took this project on. The first complex above is up, the second is down and the third is. Validation of the modified sgarbossa criteria core em. The sgarbossa criteria is used in the diagnosis of an acute myocardial infarction when a left bundle branch block is present. Sgarbossa criteria in left bundle branch block in a hypertensive.
Sgarbossas criteria can be used in cases of patients with a preexisting lbbb a pacemaker or a new lbbb, to determine the likelihood of myocardial. Calculate is a nextgeneration clinical calculator and decision support tool freely available to the medical community. In 1996 sgarbossa et al 3 identified three ekg criteria that may improve the diagnosis of stemi in patients with left bundle branch block 1. Identifying stemi in the presence of lbbb sgarbossas. Left bundle branch block lbbb is a cardiac conduction abnormality seen on the electrocardiogram ecg. Specificity of the modified criteria was not statistically different from the original weighted criteria 99% vs 100%, p. Discussion with a cardiologist should precede activation of the cath lab. Sep 16, 20 the sgarbossa criteria is described in the cardiology literature by neeland et al who conclude in their paper. In patients with left bundle branch block lbbb or ventricular paced rhythm, infarct diagnosis based on the ecg is difficult.
Identifying ami in the presence of lbbb sgarbossas criteria part i prehospital 12lead ecg 58 year old female cc. In 1996, sgarbossa et al looked through the gusto1 trial patients with lbbb and ami. My current case is a hypertensive emergency patient with acute chest pain and left bundle branch block. Enhancing the sgarbossa criteria for the diagnosis of st. In fact, in normal conduction, st elevation on the ecg is only about 70% sensitive for the diagnosis of coronary occlusion. Electrocardiographic diagnosis of evolving acute myocardial. Accurate recognition of st elevation myocardial infarction stemi in the presence of left bundle branch block lbbb remains a challenge. Sgarbossa criteria for left bundle branch block lbbb calculator. The electrocardiographic criteria for the diagnosis of infarction were then tested in an independent sample of patients presenting with acute chest pain and left bundlebranch block. Chest pain conclusion prehospital 12lead ecg 62 year old male cc. A retrospective casecontrol study am heart j, 2015 background it has been recognized since the 1940s that the presence of a left bundle branch block lbbb obscures the ekg diagnosis of myocardial infarction mi. The sgarbossa ecg criteria are the most validated tool. The presence of a complete lbbb makes the diagnosis of myocardial infarction by ecg difficult. Sgarbossa criteria for left bundle branch block lbbb.
Subsequent modifications make it even more accurate. Stemi called in the face of lbbb can be embarrassing but it doesnt have to be. Validation of the modified sgarbossa criteria for acute. Sep 07, 2016 a brief description of how to identify an mi in the presence of lbbb and paced rhythm. Editor,we read with interest the paper about the electrocardiographic diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction ami in patients with left bundle branch block lbbb. Sgarbossa s criteria are a set of electrocardiographic findings generally used to identify myocardial infarction also called acute myocardial infarction or a heart attack in the presence of a left bundle branch block lbbb or a ventricular paced rhythm. Here is a graphic i created to help explain sgarbossas criteria for identifying acute myocardial infarction ami in the presence of left bundle branch block lbbb or paced rhythm. Stephen smith presented a set of modified sgarbossa criteria, hoping to increase the sensitivity of this tool, while still maintaining a. Sgarbossas criteria were initially very weak and, over. Oct 18, 2016 the sgarbossa criteria consist of stsegment elevation of 1 mm or more concordant with the qrs complex i. If you recall there are two main problems with using 5 mm as an arbitrary cutoff for discordant stelevation in the presence of left bundle branch block. The sgarbossa electrocardiography criteria are the most validated tool to aid in the. The left bundlebranch block puzzle in the 20 stelevation myocardial infarction guideline.
Dec 02, 2015 current ecg ep 4 sgarbossa criteria stemi lbbb duration. In this final part of the series id like to talk about smiths modification to sgarbossa s criteria and the importance of serial ecgs. The modified sgarbossa criteria were superior to the original criteria for identifying aco in lbbb. The reason the original sgarbossa criteria are limited in clinical practice is the low sensitivity 20%. Dec 15, 2008 identifying ami in the presence of lbbb sgarbossas criteria part i prehospital 12lead ecg 58 year old female cc. In this final part of the series id like to talk about smiths modification to sgarbossas criteria and the importance of serial ecgs. Cardiology, lbbb, sgarbossa criteria, stemi september 29th, 2016 leave a comment it has been recognized since the 1940s that the presence of a left bundle branch block lbbb obscures the. The sgarbossas criteria for mi in left bundle branch block diagnoses acute mi in patients with prior left bundle branch block lbbb.
I think the idea of area under the lbbb curve is a good one. Patients with a suspected acs in the setting of lbbb represent a much more heterogeneous population than stemi without bbb and present unique diagnostic and therapeutic challenges to the clinician. Stemi in the presence of lbbb emergency physicians monthly. The sgarbossa criteria help with that determination. In lbbb, the normal direction of septal depolarisation is reversed becomes right to left, as the impulse spreads first to the rv via the right bundle branch and then to the lv via the septum. Apr 27, 2015 making sense of sgarbossas criteria chest pain and left bundle branch block part 3 in this final part of the series id like to talk about smiths modification to sgarbossas criteria pdf and the importance of serial ecgs. The post test prob of a negative mod sgarbossa would be incredibly low. The original, weighted, sgarbossa criteria sgarbossa 1996 has an excellent specificity at 99%, but only a sensitivity of about 50%. A 76yearold woman presents to the ed with chest pain that radiates to the neck, jaw and teeth.
Sgarbossas criteria for mi in left bundle branch block mdcalc. Dec 03, 20 the modified sgarbossa criteria is more sensitive than the original sgarbossa criteria for predicting ami in the presence of lbbb, but needs an external validation study before we can begin to apply it. Among 180 patients who presented with cardiac complaints and a new lbbb, the incidence of ami was rare, with one patient fulfilling sgarbossa and modified sgarbossa criteria. Sgarbossa criteria in bundle branch blocks and paced.
The sgarbossa criteria consist of stsegment elevation of 1 mm or more concordant with the qrs complex i. Identify all potential conflicts of interest that might be relevant to your comment. Validation of smith modified sgarbossa criteria published in american heart journal. The takehome message is that sgarbossa criteria are very specific but not sensitive 8. Increases sn from 52% 91% at the expense of reducing sp from 98% 90% sgarbossa original criteria. Notably, they have similar usefulness whether the lbbb. A brief description of how to identify an mi in the presence of lbbb and paced rhythm. Sgarbossa criteria can help interpret the ecg for stemi in the setting of lbbb.
The pain is associated with nausea, dyspnea, and diaphoresis. Validation of the modified sgarbossa criteria filed under. Current ecg ep 4 sgarbossa criteria stemi lbbb duration. The baseline st segments and t waves tend to be shifted in a discordant direction appropriate discordance, which can mask or mimic acute myocardial infarction. With most lbbbs there is what is called appropriate disconcordance. Sgarbossa criteria for acute myocardial infarction mi in the setting of endocardial right ventricular paced rhythm or left bundlebranch block. Making sense of sgarbossas criteria chest pain and left bundle branch block part 3. Making sense of sgarbossas criteria chest pain and left bundle. The most important change is the modification of the rule for excessive discordance the use of a 5 mm cutoff for excessive discordance was arbitrary and nonspecific for example, patients with lbbb and large voltages will commonly have. In other words, the modified sgarbossa criteria only changes the last of the original sgarbossa criteria with the first two criteria staying intact. Left bundle branch block presents a dilemma for many clinicians in the evaluation of chest pain or other signs and symptoms of acs and its easy to see why. In the original sgarbossa criteria, a score of 91% at the expense of reducing sp from 98% 90% sgarbossa original criteria.
Recognizable as the criteria looking at the lbbb in ami to honor the work of sgarbossa et al. Lbbb, however sgarbossa et al in 1996 described some ecg changes. The modified sgarbossa criteria replaces the absolute 5mm discordant st elevation with a proportion st elevationswave amplitude. Advised aortic dissection detection risk score plus ddimer for aortic syndromes rule out aortic dissection and other aortic syndromes smithmodified sgarbossas criteria for mi in left bundle branch block diagnose acute mi in patients with known lbbb sgarbossas criteria for mi in left bundle branch block allows for the diagnosis of. Sgarbossa criteria for acute myocardial infarction article pdf available in canadian medical association journal 18815 april 2016 with 623 reads how we measure reads. Sgarbossa criteria for left bundle branch block lbbb helps diagnose st elevation acute myocardial infarction in the presence of left bundle branch block lbbb. Left bundle branch block lbbb statpearls ncbi bookshelf. Nov 07, 2015 we have completed and published the external validation of the modified sgarbossa criteria for diagnosis of acute coronary occlusion in the presence of left bundle branch block. This is why a new lbbb alone is no longer a criteria for emergent cath lab activation. Modified sgarbossa criteria 10 april,2015 antoine ayer left bundle branch block lbbb preclude the detection of stemi because the st segment is usually deviated in all leads in the presence of lbbb. In this condition, activation of the left ventricle of the heart is delayed, which causes the left ventricle to contract later than the right ventricle. This opens the possibility of missing a large percentage acute mis. Criteria to diagnose acute mi in patients with prior lbbb.
Sgarbossa criteria background in patients with left bundle branch block lbbb or ventricular paced rhythm, infarct diagnosis based on the ecg is difficult. The sgarbossa criteria is described in the cardiology literature by neeland et al who conclude in their paper. Pdf introduction in patients presenting with chest pain, the presence of left bundle branch block lbbb on the ecg may obscure the. Acute myocardial infarction in patients with left bundle.
As discussed in this article by stephen smith, modified sgarbossa criteria have been created to improve diagnostic accuracy. This case report evaluates the sgarbossa criteria for the diagnosis of st elevation myocardial infarction and points to recent improvements in the criteria. Some valuable criteria help diagnose true stemi in patients with lbbb and symptoms suggestive of ami. Pdf sgarbossa criteria for acute myocardial infarction. In the original sgarbossa criteria, a score of apr 23, 2015 making sense of sgarbossas criteria chest pain and left bundle branch block part 1. In 1996 sgarbossa et al 3 identified three ekg criteria that may improve the diagnosis of stemi in patients with left bundle branch block. Cardiovascular 4 comments the recognition of stsegment elevation myocardial infarction stemi in the presence of left bundlebranch block lbbb remains difficult and frustrating to both emergency medicine physicians and cardiologists. The picture above is the best illustration i could find. Making sense of sgarbossa s criteria chest pain and left bundle branch block part 3. Below the form you can read more about the original and the modified version and some guidelines on lbbb.
In patients with left bundle branch block lbbb or ventricular paced rhythm, infarct diagnosis based on the ecg is difficult the baseline st segments and t waves tend to be shifted in a discordant direction appropriate discordance, which can mask or mimic acute myocardial infarction. Depolarization of the left ventricle will be carried out by impulses spreading from the right ventricle. In the original sgarbossa criteria, a score of lbbb. Sgarbossa s is a well accepted approach at determining which lbbb are having an mi. Smithmodified sgarbossas criteria for mi in left bundle branch block diagnose acute mi in patients with known lbbb sgarbossa. Now he is a 4th year student at duke, interviewing for emergency medicine residency. The three classical sgarbossa ecg criteria for myocardial infarction in the presence of a lbbb. New lbbb as a stemi equivalent is rare with low and varying diagnostic sensitivities for both the sgarbossa and modified sgarbossa criteria. An elderly patient with a history of cad and a known lbbb presents to the ed with acute onset of chest pain. Left bundle branch block lbbb litfl ecg library diagnosis. Changes the 3rd rule of original sgarbossas criteria to be st depression or elevation discordant with the qrs complex and with a magnitude of at least 25% of the qrs. Smith himself also wrote of a nice case for ep monthly about his modified criteria. Making sense of sgarbossas criteria ecg medical training. Sep 29, 2016 validation of the modified sgarbossa criteria for acute cornoary occlusion in the setting of left bundle branch block.
Diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction in left bundle branch block. Ideally, diagnostic tests for lifethreatening conditions i. Myocardial infarction mi is often difficult to detect when lbbb is present on ecg. Its often difficult to identify an mi for patients with existing left bundle branch blocks lbbb. There are many reasons for the mistaken idea that mi cannot be diagnosed in the presence of lbbb and they go way back in history, but are beyond. Myocardial infarction diagnosis in the presence of left bundle branch block lbbb or ventricular paced rhythm. Normally the septum is activated from left to right, producing small q waves in the lateral leads. Lbbb do have stemi, and denying reperfusion therapy could be fatal. The sgarbossa criteria have not been incorporated into the aha stemi guidelines and new lbbb has been removed from the current aha recommendations for activation of pci.
934 737 364 187 868 1107 1614 514 564 1434 379 713 564 1318 326 558 118 1075 1031 1347 1287 360 61 228 1436 1588 610 1196 1573 1447 449 1099 449 423 311 731 325 608 644 736 1275 1343 1499 547 178 251